A Strong Jobs Report and Rising Prices Put the Federal Reserve in a Difficult Position. Tuesday’s Inflation Report Could Change Everything.
The October jobs report showed hiring far stronger than expected, and it leaves the Federal Reserve caught between a solid labour market and inflation that is still running hot.
Read also: Democrats Take Control of Congress: What the 2026 Midterm Results Mean for the American Economy
Employers added 165,000 jobs in October, the Bureau of Labor Statistics said on November 6, far above the roughly 59,000 economists polled by Dow Jones had expected. A Reuters poll had put the consensus at 65,000. The unemployment rate held at 4.1%, with 7.1 million people unemployed, and the rate has now stayed in a 4.1% to 4.3% range since March.
The report also revised earlier months up. September hiring was revised to 60,000 from 29,000, and August to 186,000 from 133,000. Hiring was broad: professional and business services added 70,000 jobs, health care 42,000, transportation and warehousing 25,000, and manufacturing 19,000.
But Tuesday brought the other side of the Fed’s problem into sharper focus. October consumer prices rose 0.4% in the month on a seasonally adjusted basis, the Bureau of Labor Statistics said on November 10 (USDL-26-1685), after rising 0.6% in September — hotter than the roughly 0.3% forecast. Core prices, which exclude food and energy, rose 0.3% in October, the third month in a row at 0.3%, above the roughly 0.2% forecast. Shelter rose 0.3%, food rose 0.5%, and energy rose 0.7% in October, after rising 5.2% in September. BLS published no year-over-year rate for October, because October 2025 prices were never collected during the 2025 shutdown; September’s 3.7% remains the last official annual rate.
The Federal Reserve held its benchmark rate at 3.75% to 4.00% on October 28, in a 10-2 vote. The two dissenters, Governor Lisa Cook and Cleveland Fed President Beth Hammack, both wanted a quarter-point increase, to 4.00% to 4.25%. It was the first meeting since the September increase, which was unanimous, and it showed the committee split over whether inflation or the labour market is the bigger risk.
Markets reacted badly to the combination. On Thursday, November 5, the S&P 500 fell 4.4% to 7,353.73, its worst day since April 2025. The Nasdaq Composite fell 5.5% to 24,315.00, and the Dow fell 3.4% to 51,523.06. On Friday, stocks recovered part of the loss: the Nasdaq rose 1.1%, the S&P 500 rose 0.3%, and the Dow fell 0.5%. For the week, the Nasdaq was down 3.4%, the S&P 500 down 2.7%, and the Dow down 0.9%.
By the numbers
| October nonfarm payrolls | +165,000 (expected about 59,000 in Dow Jones poll; 65,000 in Reuters poll) |
| Unemployment rate | 4.1% (7.1 million unemployed) |
| September payrolls revised | 60,000 (from 29,000); August revised to 186,000 (from 133,000) |
| Average hourly earnings | $38.00, up 0.4% in the month, up 3.1% over the year |
| Underemployment (U-6) | 7.9%, up from 7.6% in September |
| October CPI | Up 0.4% in the month (seasonally adjusted), after +0.6% in September; forecast about +0.3%; no year-over-year rate published |
| October core CPI | Up 0.3% in the month, the third month in a row at +0.3%; forecast about +0.2% |
| October shelter, food and energy | Shelter +0.3%; food +0.5%; energy +0.7% (after +5.2% in September) |
| September CPI | Up 0.6% in the month, up 3.7% over the year |
| September core CPI | Up 0.3% in the month, up 2.6% over the year |
| September gasoline | Up 9.1% in the month, up 34.2% over the year; over half of the monthly CPI rise |
| Federal funds rate | 3.75% to 4.00% (held October 28, 10-2 vote) |
| S&P 500, November 5 | Down 4.36% to 7,353.73 |
| Nasdaq Composite, November 5 | Down 5.52% to 24,315.00 |
| Dow, November 5 | Down 3.44% to 51,523.06 |
| US regular gasoline, week of November 2 | $4.153 a gallon (down $0.116 from the week before, up $1.134 from a year ago) |
Investor perspective
For investors, the jobs report removed one worry and added another. Strong hiring means the economy is not sliding toward recession, which is good for company earnings. But it also means the Federal Reserve has less reason to cut interest rates, and the October inflation numbers give it a reason to consider raising them instead.
The split vote on October 28 matters here. Two policymakers wanted a rate increase, and that was before the strong October jobs report. Tuesday’s inflation report came in hotter than expected — headline CPI rose 0.4% in October, above the roughly 0.3% forecast, and core CPI rose 0.3%, above the roughly 0.2% forecast — so the December 8-9 meeting becomes a live question: hold, or hike. The October CPI report is the last inflation data the Fed will see before that meeting, because the November CPI is not published until December 10, the day after the meeting ends.
There is a catch with Tuesday’s report that investors need to understand. The Bureau of Labor Statistics did not publish a year-over-year inflation rate for October. It did not collect prices in October 2025, during the federal shutdown that year, so there is no October 2025 index to compare against. The monthly change is the number that matters this time. It came in at 0.4% for headline CPI, above the roughly 0.3% forecast, and 0.3% for core CPI, above the roughly 0.2% forecast and the third month in a row at 0.3%. September’s 3.7% is the last official annual rate until the November report on December 10.
Bond markets will move on that monthly number. The 0.4% reading, above the roughly 0.3% forecast, strengthens the case for a December hike and could push yields up. Either way, the days of assuming the next Fed move is a cut are over for now.
Customer perspective
For households, the picture is mixed in a way most people will feel directly. Jobs are plentiful and wages are rising: average hourly earnings reached $38.00 in October, up 3.1% over the year. But prices rose faster. September inflation was 3.7% over the year, which means pay, on average, lost a little ground against prices.
Gasoline is the price most people see every week. Regular gasoline averaged $4.153 a gallon in the week of November 2, according to the Energy Information Administration, down $0.116 from the week before but up $1.134 from a year ago. Gasoline was also the main driver of September’s inflation jump, rising 9.1% in a single month and accounting for more than half of the rise in the overall price index.
The practical consequence of the Fed’s dilemma is the cost of borrowing. If the Fed holds rates higher for longer, or raises them in December, mortgage rates, car loans and credit card rates stay high. If inflation cools and the Fed can cut next year, borrowing costs should ease. Tuesday’s inflation report, which came in hotter than expected, is the latest piece of evidence either way.
Employee perspective
For workers, the jobs report is genuinely good news, with a warning underneath. Employers added 165,000 jobs, hiring was spread across services, health care, transport and manufacturing, and earlier months were revised up. That is a labour market that is still creating opportunities.
The warning is in the underemployment rate. The broadest measure of labour underuse, known as U-6, rose to 7.9% in October from 7.6% in September. The number of people working part time because they could not find full-time work rose by 339,000 to 4.8 million. That suggests that while jobs are being created, some workers are not getting the hours or the roles they want.
Wage growth of 3.1% over the year is solid, but it is below the 3.7% inflation rate, so the average worker’s pay bought slightly less than a year ago. The balance of power is still with workers in hiring, but the cost of living is eating into the gains.
Synthesis: what to watch next
The economy is giving the Federal Reserve two opposite signals at once: a strong jobs market that argues against cutting rates, and inflation that is still too high, which argues for raising them. The October 28 vote showed the committee is already split, with two members wanting a hike. Tuesday’s inflation report, which came in hotter than expected, is the deciding piece of evidence before the December meeting.
Watch for: the October CPI release, published Tuesday, November 10, at 8:30 AM ET — headline CPI up 0.4% in the month and core CPI up 0.3%, both hotter than forecast, with no year-over-year rate published; the October Producer Price Index on Friday, November 13, at 8:30 AM ET; and the Federal Reserve’s December 8-9 meeting, where the choice is now between holding rates and raising them.
Primary sources
- Bureau of Labor Statistics, Employment Situation, October 2026 (released November 6, 2026): https://www.bls.gov/news.release/empsit.nr0.htm
- Bureau of Labor Statistics, Consumer Price Index, October 2026 (released November 10, 2026; USDL-26-1685): https://www.bls.gov/news.release/cpi.nr0.htm
- Bureau of Labor Statistics, Consumer Price Index, September 2026 (released October 14, 2026): https://www.bls.gov/news.release/cpi.nr0.htm
- Federal Reserve, FOMC statement, October 28, 2026: https://www.federalreserve.gov/newsevents/pressreleases/monetary20261028a.htm
- US Energy Information Administration, gasoline and diesel prices: https://www.eia.gov/petroleum/gasdiesel/
- October CPI preview, on the missing year-over-year rate (BLS did not collect October 2025 prices): https://www.piptheory.com/research/us-cpi-october-2026-preview-november-10-no-annual-rate-dollar
Note: Investment calculations and projections are for illustrative purposes only and do not constitute investment advice. Please do your own research before making any investment decisions.




